When my dinner guest and I showed up for our reservation at Sushi by Scratch Restaurants at 2331 Sixth Avenue, it took a moment for us to figure out if we were at the right place. The entrance is unassuming, windows are blocked off, and there’s no obvious signage until you’re right there at the door. A small gold sign let us you know we were indeed where we were supposed to be:
Sushi by Scratch Restaurants
Serving omakase nightly by appointment only. Please ring bell for service.
Ok then!
Once we were greeted, we found ourselves in a small standing room/whiskey bar where we sipped on welcome cocktails. With thousands of names on the waiting list and the tease of exclusivity at the front door, I was expecting a stuffy dining experience. But dinner at Sushi by Scratch Restaurants didn’t feel that way at all. It was remarkably chill—think quiet speakeasy but with a 17-course omakase-only menu featuring a mixture of locally sourced seafood and fresh imports from Japan. We were at the thoughtful mercy of a pair of highly experienced sushi chefs and a head chef who orchestrates the experience and explains the courses. The conversation was lively, and the food was outstanding.